Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 25 of 80
The four strings of a violin all have a vibrating length of 0.33 m , and for comfort and an even feel under the bow…
Question 255 marksMedium
The four strings of a violin all have a vibrating length of 0.33m, and for comfort and an even feel under the bow each is tuned with roughly the same tension, 50N. Their open fundamental frequencies are G 196Hz, D 294Hz, A 440Hz and E 659Hz.
(a) Show that the mass per unit length a string needs is μ=T/(2Lν)2, and find it for each of the four strings.
(b) If the G and E strings were made of the same material, what would be the ratio of their diameters?
(c) Explain why instrument makers give the low strings extra mass (thicker, or wound with wire) instead of making them longer.
(a) For the fundamental of a string fixed at both ends, ν=2Lv with v=T/μ. So
2Lν=μT⇒μ=(2Lν)2T
With T=50N and 2L=0.66m:
String
ν (Hz)
v=2Lν (m s−1)
μ (kg m−1)
G
196
129.4
2.99×10−3
D
294
194.0
1.33×10−3
A
440
290.4
5.93×10−4
E
659
434.9
2.64×10−4
For example, for G: μ=50/(0.66×196)2=50/129.42=2.99×10−3kg m−1. At fixed T and L, μ∝1/ν2, so the G string must be (659/196)2=11.3 times heavier per metre than the E string.
(b) For one material μ=ρπd2/4∝d2, so d∝μ∝1/ν:
dEdG=νGνE=196659=3.36
(c) At the same tension and μ, the frequency is inversely proportional to the length, so lowering E to G by length alone would need a string 3.36×0.33=1.11m long, far longer than a violin and impossible to finger. Lowering the pitch with tension instead would need (196/659)2≈0.09 of the tension, leaving a floppy string. Increasing μ keeps the length and tension the same for all four strings, so the instrument stays playable and every string feels the same under the bow. A plain gut or steel string 3.36 times thicker would be stiff, so makers wind a heavy metal wire around a thin core: this adds mass per unit length without adding much stiffness.