Any group that stabilises the phenoxide ion (by withdrawing electrons) increases acidity. Any group that destabilises it (by releasing electrons) decreases acidity. –OCH3 has two opposing effects:
- –I effect: oxygen is more electronegative than carbon, so it withdraws electrons through the σ bonds. This works at every position and weakens with distance.
- +R effect: an oxygen lone pair is released into the ring. This reaches only the carbons ortho and para to the –OCH3 group.
(a) At the para position, the +R effect of –OCH3 pushes electron density onto the carbon that carries the O− of the phenoxide ion. This adds to the negative charge and destabilises the ion. +R outweighs the –I effect (which is weak so far away), so 4-methoxyphenol (10.2) is weaker than phenol (10.0).
At the meta position, the +R effect cannot reach the carbon that carries the O− (resonance places charge only ortho and para to the –OCH3). Only the electron-withdrawing –I effect acts. It stabilises the phenoxide ion, so 3-methoxyphenol (9.65) is stronger than phenol.
(b) –CH3 has no electronegative atom. It releases electrons by +I and hyperconjugation, and has no electron-withdrawing effect at any position. So it destabilises the phenoxide ion wherever it is, and 3-methylphenol (10.1) and 4-methylphenol (10.2) are both weaker than phenol. The difference at the meta position comes from the electronegative oxygen of –OCH3 (–I), which –CH3 does not have.
(c) Stronger. In 3,5-dimethoxyphenol, both –OCH3 groups are meta to the –OH. Neither can release electrons to the O−-bearing carbon by resonance, and both withdraw electrons by –I. The two –I effects add up and stabilise the phenoxide ion more than one group does. So 3,5-dimethoxyphenol should have a lower pKa than 9.65. Its measured value, about 9.35, confirms the prediction.
