Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 73 of 80
Four alcohols are shaken separately with Lucas reagent (conc.
Question 732 marksMedium
Four alcohols are shaken separately with Lucas reagent (conc. HCl + anhydrous ZnCl2) at room temperature: propan-1-ol, cyclohexanol, 2-methylpropan-2-ol and benzyl alcohol (C6H5CH2OH).
(a) Benzyl alcohol is a primary alcohol, yet it turns cloudy almost as fast as 2-methylpropan-2-ol. Explain, using the intermediate formed, and give the order in which the four solutions turn cloudy. [1]
(b) A student finds that an unknown aromatic alcohol (it contains a benzene ring) of formula C7H8O gives immediate turbidity and concludes that it is tertiary. Show that this conclusion cannot be right, and suggest one chemical test that would confirm its true class. [1]
(a) The Lucas reaction goes through a carbocation (ZnCl2 helps the protonated –OH leave). The faster the carbocation forms, the sooner the insoluble alkyl chloride makes the solution cloudy.
C6H5CH2OH+HClZnCl2C6H5CH2Cl+H2O
The benzyl carbocation, C6H5C+H2, is primary, but its positive charge is delocalised by resonance onto the two ortho carbons and the para carbon of the ring. This makes it about as stable as a tertiary carbocation, so it forms easily and turbidity appears at once. An ordinary primary carbocation (from propan-1-ol) has no such stabilisation.
Order of appearance of turbidity: 2-methylpropan-2-ol ≈ benzyl alcohol (immediately) > cyclohexanol (2°, after a few minutes) > propan-1-ol (1°, no turbidity at room temperature).
(b) A tertiary alcohol needs a carbon bearing –OH that is bonded to three other carbons. The benzene ring (C6) accounts for all 4 degrees of unsaturation of C7H8O and leaves only one more carbon. If –OH were on a ring carbon the compound would be a phenol (a cresol), not an alcohol, so –OH must be on that extra carbon, which is bonded to only one carbon (the ring). The smallest aromatic tertiary alcohol, C6H5C(OH)(CH3)2, already has 9 carbons. So a C7H8O alcohol cannot be tertiary. It is benzyl alcohol, and the fast Lucas result comes from its resonance-stabilised benzylic carbocation.
Confirming test: oxidise it with PCC (or acidified K2Cr2O7). Benzyl alcohol is oxidised to benzaldehyde (and on to benzoic acid with K2Cr2O7), for example turning orange dichromate green. A tertiary alcohol is not oxidised. So oxidation shows the alcohol is primary.