(a) For P: doubling [RBr] doubles the rate (Expt 1 → 2), and doubling [OH−] leaves it unchanged (Expt 1 → 3). First order in P, zero order in OH−:
rate=k[P]k=0.0101.2×10−4=1.2×10−2 s−1
For Q: doubling either concentration doubles the rate (Expt 4 → 5 and 4 → 6). First order in each:
rate=k[Q][OH−]k=0.010×0.0103.0×10−6=3.0×10−2 L mol−1 s−1
(b) P reacts by SN1 (unimolecular: only P in the rate law) and Q by SN2 (bimolecular).
P is a tertiary and benzylic bromide. On ionisation it gives a carbocation that is stabilised by two alkyl groups (hyperconjugation and +I effect) and, more strongly, by resonance with the benzene ring, which spreads the positive charge over the ring. The C–Br carbon is also too crowded for back-side attack. So the slow step is ionisation, and OH− joins only afterwards. Q is a secondary halide with no such stabilisation, and with the strong nucleophile OH− it reacts in one step.
(c)
- From P: optically inactive. The planar carbocation is attacked from both faces equally, so the product is racemic (±)-2-phenylbutan-2-ol.
- From Q: optically active. OH− attacks from the side opposite to Br, so pentan-2-ol is formed with inverted configuration and remains optically active.
