Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 77 of 80
Read the passage and answer the questions that follow.
Question 774 marksHard
Read the passage and answer the questions that follow.
NCERT gives the conditions needed to replace the chlorine atom by –OH in these four haloarenes:
Compound
Conditions for Cl → OH
W, chlorobenzene
aqueous NaOH, 623 K, 300 atm, then H+
X, 1-chloro-4-nitrobenzene
aqueous NaOH, 443 K, then H+
Y, 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene
aqueous NaOH, 368 K, then H+
Z, 2-chloro-1,3,5-trinitrobenzene
warm water, 322 K
(i) The steady fall in the temperature needed from W to Z is best explained by: (A) each –NO2 group pushes electrons into the ring and weakens the C–Cl bond (B) each –NO2 group ortho or para to Cl gives one more place where the negative charge of the intermediate can be spread onto oxygen atoms (C) each –NO2 group stabilises the phenyl cation, making SN1 easier (D) the –NO2 groups lengthen the C–Cl bond by steric crowding [1]
(ii) Name the product formed from Z, and explain why water alone is a strong enough nucleophile for Z. [1]
(iii) Why must the reaction of W at 623 K be carried out under a pressure of 300 atm, and why does Y need neither a high temperature nor a high pressure? [1]
(iv) Why must the reaction mixture be acidified to obtain the phenol from W, X and Y, but not from Z? [1]
(i) — (B).OH− adds to the carbon carrying Cl and the negative charge appears at the positions ortho and para to it. Every –NO2 group at one of these positions lets the charge spread onto its oxygen atoms. X has one such group, Y has two (2 and 4) and Z has three (2, 4 and 6), so the intermediate becomes more stable and forms more easily at each step, and the temperature needed falls.
(A) is wrong: –NO2 withdraws electrons. (C) is wrong: a phenyl cation is not stabilised by resonance and haloarenes do not react by SN1. (D) is wrong: nothing in the mechanism involves the –NO2 groups stretching the C–Cl bond; their effect is electronic.
(ii) Z gives 2,4,6-trinitrophenol (picric acid):
C6H2(NO2)3Cl+H2O322KC6H2(NO2)3OH+HCl
With –NO2 groups on all three positions (2, 4, 6) that carry the negative charge, the intermediate is so strongly stabilised that even the weak nucleophile H2O can add to the ring carbon.
(iii)Why W needs 300 atm. The nucleophile OH− is dissolved in water, whose normal boiling point is 373 K. At 623 K and 1 atm the water would boil away as steam, leaving no liquid NaOH solution in contact with the chlorobenzene. The vapour pressure of water at 623 K is about 163 atm, so a pressure of 300 atm keeps the water liquid, and OH− stays dissolved and in contact with the haloarene in a closed vessel. The high temperature itself is needed because the C–Cl bond of chlorobenzene has partial double-bond character and the intermediate formed by adding OH− has no –NO2 group to stabilise its negative charge.
Why Y needs neither. Y has two –NO2 groups (at C-2 and C-4) ortho and para to Cl, which spread the negative charge of the intermediate onto their oxygen atoms. The reaction is therefore fast enough at 368 K, which is below 373 K, so the aqueous NaOH does not boil and no extra pressure is required; an open flask under reflux is enough.
(iv) Phenols are acidic, and nitrophenols are more acidic still. In the excess NaOH used for W, X and Y, the phenol formed is converted into its sodium phenoxide salt (e.g. sodium 4-nitrophenoxide), which stays dissolved. Adding acid (H+) converts the phenoxide back into the free phenol. Z reacts with water alone, with no base present, so picric acid is formed directly and acidification is not needed.