Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 65 of 80
Roofs in a cyclone.
Question 655 marksHard
Roofs in a cyclone. During a cyclone a wind of 40m s−1 blows horizontally over the flat roof of a house. The roof has an area of 150m2 and a mass of 8000kg, and simply rests on the walls without being fixed. The windows are shut, so the air inside is still and at the pressure of the still air outside. Take the density of air as 1.2kg m−3 and g=9.8m s−2.
(a) Find the difference between the air pressure below and above the roof.
(b) Find the net vertical force on the roof. Will the roof be lifted off?
(c) What is the least wind speed at which the roof would just be lifted?
(d) State the assumptions you made in applying Bernoulli's principle and comment on whether each is reasonable here.
(a) Take a streamline from the still air far from the house (speed zero, at the same pressure as the still air inside the house) to the air moving over the roof at v=40m s−1, at about the same height. By Bernoulli's equation,
Pbelow−Pabove=21ρv2=21×1.2×402=960Pa
The pressure above the roof is lower by 960Pa, under one-hundredth of an atmosphere.
(b) Upward force due to the pressure difference:
F=ΔP×A=960×150=1.44×105N
Weight of the roof: mg=8000×9.8=7.84×104N.
Net upward force =1.44×105−7.84×104=6.56×104N. The upward force is almost twice the weight, so the roof is lifted off.
(c) The roof just lifts when 21ρv2A=mg:
v=ρA2mg=1.2×1502×7.84×104=871=29.5m s−1
Any wind faster than about 30m s−1 (about 106km h−1) would lift this roof.
(d) Assumptions:
Steady flow: the wind is taken as steady along a streamline. Gusts make the real flow unsteady, so the actual force fluctuates about this estimate.
Non-viscous fluid: air has a very small viscosity, so energy losses over the roof are small; this is reasonable.
Incompressible fluid: at 40m s−1 the pressure changes are below 1% of atmospheric pressure, so the density of air hardly changes; this is reasonable.
Same height: the still air far from the house and the air just over the roof are at about the same height, and with air's low density any small height difference makes the ρgh term negligible.
The result explains why roofs that are not tied down to the walls are torn off in cyclones.