An engineer tests two materials, P and Q, in tension and obtains the stress–strain curves shown (drawn to the same scale). The crosses mark the points where the specimens break.

Which of the two materials is brittle, and why?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 9 of 80
An engineer tests two materials, P and Q, in tension and obtains the stress–strain curves shown (drawn to the same scale). The crosses mark the points where the specimens break.

Which of the two materials is brittle, and why?
(A) P, because its ultimate tensile strength is smaller than that of Q
(B) P, because it undergoes a very large strain before it breaks
(C) Q, because its fracture point comes almost immediately after its ultimate tensile strength
(D) Neither, because both curves have a straight portion in which Hooke's law is obeyed
Option (C) is correct.
Explanation: Whether a material is brittle or ductile depends on how far apart its ultimate tensile strength point and its fracture point lie on the stress–strain curve. If they are close, the material is brittle; if they are far apart, it is ductile.
For Q, the stress reaches its maximum (about 480 MPa) at a strain of about , and Q breaks almost at once, at a strain of about . So Q is brittle, even though it is the stiffer and the stronger material.
For P, the maximum stress (about 260 MPa) is reached at a strain of about , but P keeps stretching until a strain of about before breaking. Its ultimate and fracture points are far apart, so P is ductile: it would give visible warning (large stretching) before failing.
(A) is wrong: a smaller ultimate strength means a weaker material, not a brittle one. Brittleness is about how the material fails, not how much stress it can take.
(B) is wrong: a large strain before fracture is the mark of a ductile material, the opposite of brittle.
(D) is wrong: nearly all materials have a linear region at small strains; a straight portion tells us nothing about brittleness.