A diver carries two thin, flexible plastic bags down a swimming pool. One holds 1.0 litre of air and the other 1.0 litre of water. He takes both bags 0.20 m deeper. Take , the density of pool water , and the bulk moduli from Table 8.3: air and water . Which statement about the decrease in volume of the two bags is correct?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 7 of 80
A diver carries two thin, flexible plastic bags down a swimming pool.
(A) Both shrink by the same amount, because the same increase in pressure acts on both
(B) The air shrinks by about and the water by about
(C) The air shrinks by about and the water by about
- Correct answer
(D) The air shrinks by about and the water by only about
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: Going 0.20 m deeper increases the pressure on each bag by
The decrease in volume of each is , with :
The same pressure change squeezes the air about twenty thousand times more than the water, because the bulk modulus of water is that many times larger. The diver would see the air bag visibly shrink, while the change in the water bag (less than a thousandth of a cubic centimetre) would be far too small for him to notice.
(A) is wrong: the pressure change is the same, but the volume strain is , and the two bulk moduli are very different.
(B) is wrong: it takes the volume as instead of .
(C) is wrong: the air value is right, but the water value uses a bulk modulus a thousand times too small ().
