(a) The punch pushes the disc out along the direction of the axis of the hole. The force is parallel to the curved cylindrical wall of the hole, so that wall, of circumference πd and height t (the plate thickness), is the sheared surface:
A=πdt=π×1.0×10−2×2.0×10−3=6.28×10−5 m2
(b)
F=σsA=3.0×108×6.28×10−5=1.88×104 N
The punch needs at least 1.88×104 N.
(c) With πr2=π(5.0×10−3)2=7.85×10−5 m2 she gets 3.0×108×7.85×10−5=2.36×104 N. This is wrong because the flat face of the disc is perpendicular to the force; a force across that face would be a compressive stress, not a shearing one. The metal that has to be cut lies around the rim. Since A=πdt, doubling the thickness doubles the force, to 3.77×104 N; her πr2 would wrongly predict no change.