(a) Equal areas: π(r22−r12)=π(1.0)2, so r12=2.02−1.02=3.0 cm2 and the inner radius is r1=1.73 cm.
(b) Both have A=π(1.0×10−2)2=3.14×10−4 m2:
σ=3.14×10−42.0×104=6.37×107 Pa,ΔL=YσL=2.0×10116.37×107×2.0=6.37×10−4 m
Both have a stress of 6.37×107 Pa and stretch by 0.637 mm. In tension (or compression) only the area of metal matters, not how it is arranged.
(c) In bending, one side of the beam is stretched and the other squeezed; the metal farthest from the middle is strained the most and gives most of the resistance, while metal near the middle does very little. The tube places all its metal far from the middle, like a beam of larger depth; since the sag of a beam falls as the cube of its depth, spreading the same metal over a larger diameter reduces the sag greatly. The rod keeps much of its metal near the middle, where it is wasted. That is why bicycle frames, scaffolding and lamp posts are made of tubes.