(i)
δ=4bd3YWl3=4×0.10×(0.30)3×13×1091.0×104×(4.0)3=1.404×1086.4×105=4.56×10−3 m
The sag is 4.56 mm.
(ii) The allowed sag is 4.0/360=1.11×10−2 m=11.1 mm. The sag is proportional to the load, so
Wmax=1.0×104×4.5611.1=2.44×104 N
The beam may carry about 2.44×104 N at its centre.
(iii) For the same sag with the same W and l, the product bd3Y must be the same:
ds3=bsYsbtdt3Yt=0.050×200×1090.10×(0.30)3×13×109=3.51×10−3 m3⇒ds=0.152 m
The steel beam must be about 0.152 m deep.
(iv) Mass per metre = (area of section) × density:
mt=0.10×0.30×525=15.8 kg,ms=0.050×0.152×7860=59.7 kg
The solid steel beam is about 3.8 times heavier than the timber beam of the same stiffness. Steel's Y is 15 times larger, but it is 15 times denser too, and the timber beam gains far more from its greater depth, since the sag goes as d−3.
(v) In a bending beam, the material near the top and bottom faces is stretched and squeezed the most and does most of the work of resisting the bending; material near the middle does little. An I-section puts most of the metal in two flanges far from the middle, joined by a thin web, so it has a large effective depth for little weight. This keeps the great advantage of depth (δ∝d−3) while cutting the mass and cost. The depth cannot be increased indefinitely with the beam made ever thinner, because a deep, thin beam buckles sideways unless the load is exactly in the right place (hard to arrange with moving loads). The flanges of the I-section give the width that prevents this buckling.