Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 63 of 80
Sizing the cables of a suspension bridge.
Question 635 marksHard
Sizing the cables of a suspension bridge. The deck of a suspension bridge hangs from two main steel cables, one on each side. The deck and its heaviest traffic together weigh 2.0×107N. In a first, simplified estimate the engineers assume that each cable carries half of this load and that the tension is the same all along the cable. Each main cable is 1000m long. For steel take Y=2.0×1011N m−2, ultimate strength σu=400MPa, yield strength σy=250MPa and density 7860kg m−3 (Table 8.1). The design uses a safety factor of 3 on the ultimate strength.
(i) Find the cross-sectional area and the diameter of each main cable.
(ii) Each cable is actually made of parallel steel wires of diameter 5.0mm. About how many wires does each cable need?
(iii) Find the working stress in a cable, and show that the cable stays within its elastic limit.
(iv) By how much does each 1000m cable stretch at the working load, and how much elastic energy does it then store?
(v) An engineer suggests aluminium cables instead (σu=110MPa, Y=70GPa, density 2710kg m−3), with the same safety factor. Find the area needed and compare the mass of one metre of cable with that of steel. Is aluminium the better choice?
(i) The allowed (working) stress is the ultimate strength divided by the safety factor:
Each cable needs an area of 0.075m2, a diameter of about 0.31m.
(ii) One wire has an area π(2.5×10−3)2=1.96×10−5m2, so the number of wires is
n=1.96×10−50.075=3.82×103
About 3820 wires per cable.
(iii) The working stress is 1.33×108Pa (from (i)). This is only 133/250=0.53 of the yield strength, so the cable stays well inside its elastic region: it returns to its original length when the traffic leaves, with no permanent set.
The energy stored is the area under the force–extension line:
U=21FΔL=21×1.0×107×0.667=3.33×106J
Each cable stretches by 0.667m and stores 3.33×106J. (Check: 21σε×AL=21×1.333×108×6.67×10−4×75=3.33×106J.) The designers must allow the deck to drop by a noticeable amount under full load.
(v) For aluminium the working stress is 110/3=36.7MPa, so
AAl=3.667×1071.0×107=0.273m2
Mass of one metre of cable:
mAl=0.273×2710=739kg,msteel=0.075×7860=590kg
The aluminium cable needs 0.273m2, over three and a half times the area, and is about 25 % heavier per metre, even though aluminium is much less dense. (It would stretch a little less, since its strain 36.7×106/70×109=5.2×10−4 is smaller, but that does not make up for it.) Its low strength outweighs its low density, and the extra weight of the cables themselves adds to the load. Steel is the better choice.