Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 58 of 80
A thin steel ring (a hoop) of radius R spins about an axis through its centre, perpendicular to its plane, so that…
Question 581 markMCQHard
A thin steel ring (a hoop) of radius R spins about an axis through its centre, perpendicular to its plane, so that every part of it moves with speed v. The only forces on any small piece of the ring are the pulls of the neighbouring parts, so the tension in the ring must supply the centripetal force. Take the density of steel as 7860kg m−3, its ultimate tensile strength as 400MPa and its yield strength as 250MPa (Table 8.1).
What is the greatest speed of the rim before the ring breaks?
Select your answer
(A) 160m s−1
(B) 226m s−1
Correct answer
(C) 319m s−1
(D) 178m s−1
Option (B) is correct.
Explanation: Work in the ground frame. Take a small piece of the ring that subtends an angle Δθ at the centre. Its mass is Δm=ρARΔθ, where A is the cross-sectional area. The tension T pulls on each end along the tangent; the two pulls are inclined at Δθ to each other, so their resultant points to the centre and has magnitude 2Tsin(Δθ/2)≈TΔθ. This supplies the centripetal force:
TΔθ=ΔmRv2=ρARΔθRv2⇒T=ρAv2⇒σ=AT=ρv2
The stress does not depend on R or A. The ring breaks when σ reaches σu:
vmax=ρσu=7860400×106=226m s−1
(A) is wrong: 160m s−1=σu/2ρ takes the inward pull as only Tsin(Δθ/2)≈TΔθ/2, counting the pull at one end of the piece and forgetting the other.
(C) is wrong: 319m s−1=2σu/ρ takes the inward pull as 2TΔθ, counting the two end pulls twice over.
(D) is wrong: 178m s−1 uses the yield strength; at that speed the ring starts to stretch permanently, but it does not break until the stress reaches the ultimate strength.