A cable maker tests two wires drawn from the same batch of steel. The diameter of wire 1 is half the diameter of wire 2. First, both wires carry the same load. Then each is loaded until it breaks. What are the ratio of the stresses (wire 1 : wire 2) under the same load, and the ratio of their breaking loads?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 17 of 80
A cable maker tests two wires drawn from the same batch of steel.
(A) Stresses ; breaking loads
(B) Stresses ; breaking loads
(C) Stresses ; breaking loads
- Correct answer
(D) Stresses ; breaking loads
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: The area is proportional to the square of the diameter, so
Under the same load, stress , so
Both wires are of the same material, so they break at the same stress, the ultimate tensile strength . The breaking load is , so
The thinner wire is more highly stressed by a given load and breaks under a quarter of the load that breaks the thicker wire.
(A) is wrong: it takes the area proportional to the diameter instead of its square.
(B) is wrong: the breaking stress is the same for both, but the breaking load depends on the area.
(C) is wrong: it inverts both ratios; the thinner wire has the larger stress and the smaller breaking load.
