A steel wire and a brass wire of the same length and the same cross-sectional area are joined end to end. The combined wire hangs from a ceiling hook and carries a load at its lower end. Take Young's modulus of steel as and of brass as , and neglect the masses of the wires. Which statement about the two wires is correct?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 16 of 80
A steel wire and a brass wire of the same length and the same cross-sectional area are joined end to end.
(A) Their extensions are equal, and the stress in the steel is twice that in the brass
(B) The stress in the steel is half that in the brass, and their extensions are equal
(C) Their stresses are equal, and the steel stretches twice as much as the brass
- Correct answer
(D) Their stresses are equal, and the steel stretches half as much as the brass
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: The wires are in series, so every cross-section of both wires carries the same tension, equal to the load . The areas are equal, so the stresses are equal:
The extension of each is . With the same and ,
The steel, with the larger Young's modulus, stretches less.
(A) is wrong: equal extensions would need equal strains, which is impossible with equal stresses and different moduli; and the stress is the same in both.
(B) is wrong: the tension, and so the stress, is the same all along a wire joined in series.
(C) is wrong: it inverts the ratio. For the same stress the extension is inversely proportional to , so the stiffer steel stretches less.
