The ear can follow changes in loudness only if they are more than about 0.1 s apart. Using the beat formula, find the time between successive loudness maxima for (i) 400 Hz with 403 Hz and (ii) 400 Hz with 450 Hz. Hence explain why beats are heard in case (i) but not in case (ii), and estimate the largest frequency difference for which beats can be heard.
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 77 of 80
The ear can follow changes in loudness only if they are more than about 0.1 s apart.
Question 772 marksHard
Two equal waves combine to . The loudness peaks times per second, so the time between maxima is .
- (i) . This is longer than 0.1 s, so the ear follows each rise and fall and hears 3 beats per second.
- (ii) . About five loudness maxima fall within each 0.1 s, so the ear cannot separate them. They merge, and the listener hears two different notes (or a rough sound) instead of beats.
The limit is reached when , that is . Beats are clearly heard only when the two frequencies differ by less than about 10 Hz. This is why musicians tune by listening for slow beats that die away as the notes are matched.
