Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 76 of 80
A microphone records the strongest frequencies from a plucked string as 165, 330, 495 and 660 Hz.
Question 762 marksHard
A microphone records the strongest frequencies from a plucked string as 165, 330, 495 and 660 Hz. From a uniform circular drumhead (no loading patch) it records 150, 239, 320 and 345 Hz.
Test each set by dividing by its lowest frequency. Then explain, from the condition that the vibration must fit the boundary, why a string fixed at both ends must give whole-number ratios while a drumhead does not.
Ratio test. String: 165:330:495:660=1:2:3:4, exact whole numbers. Drumhead: 150:239:320:345=1:1.59:2.13:2.30, which are not whole numbers.
String. Both ends must be nodes, and the wave speed v=T/μ is the same for every mode. A standing wave fits only if a whole number of half-wavelengths spans the string, L=nλ/2, so
νn=2Lnv=nν1,n=1,2,3,…
The one-dimensional fitting condition forces every allowed frequency to be an exact multiple of ν1.
Drumhead. The membrane is two-dimensional, and its whole circular rim must stay still. Its modes have nodal lines (diameters and circles), not nodal points along a line. Fitting such patterns to a circular boundary is not the same as fitting whole half-wavelengths into a fixed length, so the allowed frequencies come out at the irregular ratios measured above. That is why a plain drum has a less definite pitch than a string. NCERT notes that the modes of a membrane are more complex than those of a string.