Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 65 of 80
A copper rod 1.2 m long is clamped at its middle and stroked along its length, so that it vibrates longitudinally.
Question 655 marksHard
A copper rod 1.2 m long is clamped at its middle and stroked along its length, so that it vibrates longitudinally. For copper Y=1.13×1011Pa and ρ=8900kg m−3.
(a) Find the speed of longitudinal waves in the rod, and compare it with the value for copper in Table 14.1 (3560m s−1).
(b) A second copper rod has the same length but twice the diameter, so it has four times the mass. It is clamped at its middle and stroked in the same way. A student expects it to sound a lower note because it is heavier. Is she right? Explain, using your result from (a).
(c) The fundamental frequency of the first rod is measured as 1485 Hz. One end of the vibrating rod is held at the mouth of a tube closed at its lower end, whose air column length can be varied. Taking the speed of sound in air as 340m s−1 and neglecting edge effects, find every air-column length up to 30 cm that resonates with the rod's fundamental.
(d) Compare the wavelength of this note in the rod with its wavelength in the air.
(a)
v=ρY=89001.13×1011=3.56×103m s−1
This agrees with the Table 14.1 value of 3560m s−1 to within 0.1 %.
(b) She is not right; the thick rod sounds the same note. The speed of longitudinal waves in the rod, v=Y/ρ, depends only on the material (its Young's modulus and density), not on the rod's thickness, so it is 3.56×103m s−1 in both rods. Physically, the thick rod has four times the mass per unit length, but it is also four times as stiff (the force needed for a given strain is YA, and A is four times larger), so the two effects cancel.
The clamp at the middle and the free ends fix the same pattern of nodes and antinodes in both rods, so each mode has the same wavelength in both. With the same speed and the same wavelength, ν=v/λ is the same: the thick rod gives the same note.
(c) In air, the 1485 Hz note has λair=340/1485=0.229m=22.9cm. A closed column resonates when its length is an odd number of quarter wavelengths:
ℓ=4λair,43λair,45λair=5.73cm,17.2cm,28.6cm
The next length, 40.1 cm, exceeds 30 cm.
(d) In the rod, λrod=v/ν=3563/1485=2.40m. The frequency is the same in both media, so the wavelengths are in the ratio of the speeds: