Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 63 of 80
A melting bullet.
Question 635 marksHard
A melting bullet. A lead bullet of mass 10.0g at 27∘C strikes a thick wooden block at 400m s−1 and stops inside it. Assume that half of its kinetic energy becomes internal energy of the bullet, and the rest goes into the wood. For lead (Tables 10.3 and 10.5): s=127.7J kg−1K−1, melting point 328∘C, Lf=0.25×105J kg−1.
(a) Find the heat that goes into the bullet, and show that it is enough to bring the bullet to its melting point. What mass of lead melts?
(b) What is the least speed at which the whole bullet would melt, on the same assumption?
(c) For lead, compare the latent heat of fusion with the heat needed to warm 1kg from 27∘C to the melting point. Use this to explain why a speed only about 26% higher than 400m s−1 melts the whole bullet.
(d) Why is the assumption about "half" the kinetic energy the weakest part of this calculation, and which way would your answers change if more than half stayed in the bullet?
(a) Kinetic energy of the bullet:
K=21mv2=21×0.0100×4002=800J
so 400J goes into the bullet. Warming it to the melting point needs
Q1=msΔT=0.0100×127.7×(328−27)=384.4J
which is less than 400J, so the bullet reaches 328∘C and the remaining 400−384.4=15.6J starts to melt it:
mmelted=0.25×10515.6=6.2×10−4kg=0.62g
(b) To melt it all, half the kinetic energy must supply m(sΔT+Lf):
The mass cancels, so the answer is the same for a bullet of any size.
(c) For lead, warming 1kg through 301K needs 127.7×301=38438J, while melting it needs only 25000J: the latent heat is the smaller part. At 400m s−1 each kilogram of the bullet receives 21×21×4002=40000J, just above the 38438J needed to reach 328∘C. Only 25000J kg−1 more is needed to melt it all, so the energy per kilogram must rise from 40000 to 63438J, a factor of 1.59; since the energy goes as v2, the speed need rise only by 1.59=1.26, from 400 to 504m s−1. Lead's low specific heat and very low latent heat make this possible.
(d) How the energy divides between the bullet and the wood depends on the details of the impact (friction, deformation, how fast heat is conducted into the wood during the stop), and cannot be calculated simply; "half" is only a guess. If more than half stayed in the bullet, more lead would melt in (a) and the speed needed in (b) would be lower. Since the speed depends on the square root of the energy, even a large error in the fraction changes the answer in (b) by a smaller proportion.