(a) With S open, only R1 is in the circuit: I=126=0.50 A, which matches the reading.
When S is closed, R2 is in parallel with R1. Each has the full 6 V across it, so the current in R1 is still 0.50 A. The extra current comes from R2:
I2=0.75−0.50=0.25 A
R2=I2V=0.256=24 Ω
(b) In series the resistances add:
R=12+24=36 Ω,I=366=61 A≈0.17 A
The reading falls to about 0.17 A, below the 0.50 A with R1 alone, because a series resistor adds to the opposition while a parallel one gives an extra path.