Three charges , and are placed at equal distances on a straight line. If the potential energy of the system of these charges is zero, then what is the ratio ?
Previous Year Questions · Question 22 of 38
Three charges -q , Q and -q are placed at equal distances on a straight line.
Concept used — potential energy of a system of point charges
The electrostatic potential energy of a system of charges is the work needed to assemble it from infinity. It is the sum of the energies of every pair of charges:
Three charges make three pairs. Write .
Given: , and on a straight line, equally spaced. Let the spacing be , so the two outer charges are apart. To find: when .

Step 1 — List the three pairs.
| Pair | Product of charges | Separation |
|---|---|---|
| left and | ||
| and right | ||
| left and right |
Step 2 — Add the pair energies.
Step 3 — Put and solve. Since , the bracket must vanish:
Divide both sides by (which is not zero):
Answer: .
Note: must be positive. The two attractive pairs ( with each ) then have negative energy, which exactly cancels the positive energy of the one repulsive pair (the two charges). A negative would make all three terms positive, and could never be zero.
