The following haloalkanes are hydrolysed in the presence of aqueous KOH.
(i) 1-Chlorobutane
(ii) 2-Chloro-2-methylpropane
Which of the above is more likely to give a racemic mixture? Justify your answer.
Confirming your payment
Previous Year Questions · Question 20 of 37
The following haloalkanes are hydrolysed in the presence of aqueous KOH.
(i) 1-Chlorobutane
(ii) 2-Chloro-2-methylpropane
Which of the above is more likely to give a racemic mixture? Justify your answer.
(ii) 2-Chloro-2-methylpropane. It is a tertiary halide and is hydrolysed by the mechanism. The C–Cl bond breaks first to give a planar tertiary carbocation, and can attack it from either face with equal probability. This two-faced attack is the step that produces a racemic mixture when the carbon is chiral.

(i) 1-Chlorobutane is a primary halide and reacts by (backside attack), which gives inversion, not racemisation.
Note: in this particular pair neither carbon is chiral, and the product 2-methylpropan-2-ol, , is itself achiral (three identical groups). So no optical rotation is actually seen. The question tests which mechanism leads to racemisation.