Which of the following is not correct?
Previous Year Questions · Question 2 of 37
Which of the following is not correct?
(A) In haloarenes, the electron pairs on the halogen atom are in conjugation with the π-electrons of the ring.
- Correct answer
(B) The carbon–magnesium bond in a Grignard reagent is covalent and non-polar in nature.
(C) During an reaction, the carbocation formed in the slow step, being hybridised, is planar.
(D) Out of and , is more reactive towards an reaction.
Option (B) is correct.
Explanation: In a Grignard reagent, , carbon (electronegativity 2.5) is bonded to the electropositive metal magnesium (1.2). The C–Mg bond is covalent but highly polar: carbon carries a partial negative charge and magnesium a partial positive charge.
That polarity is exactly why the alkyl group behaves like a carbanion and pulls a proton from water to give an alkane. Calling the bond "non-polar" is wrong, so (B) is the incorrect statement.
Why the other statements are correct:
- (A) A lone pair on the halogen overlaps with the π-system of the ring (resonance). This gives the C–X bond partial double bond character.
- (C) In the C–X bond breaks first. The carbocation is hybridised and trigonal planar, which is why the nucleophile can attack from either face.
- (D) Benzyl chloride ionises to a benzyl carbocation stabilised by resonance with the ring. Vinyl chloride would have to form a vinyl cation, which is not stabilised, and its C–Cl bond has partial double bond character. So benzyl chloride reacts much faster by .
