The figure below shows two competing routes when a haloalkane reacts with water in the presence of ethanol at 65 °C.
Question 334 marksAsked 2020Hard
The figure below shows two competing routes when a haloalkane reacts with water in the presence of ethanol at 65 °C. The product of each route is shown.
(i) Explain the mechanism of both these reactions.
(ii) Which of the two reactions will predominate? Give reasons.
The haloalkane is 2-chloro-2-methylpropane, (CH3)3CCl, a tertiary halide. Route 1 gives 2-methylpropan-2-ol, (CH3)3COH (substitution). Route 2 gives 2-methylpropene, (CH3)2C=CH2 (elimination).
(i) Both routes start with the same slow step, because a tertiary halide is too crowded for backside (SN2) attack but ionises easily in a polar protic solvent such as water/ethanol:
(CH3)3C–Clslow(CH3)3C++Cl−
The planar tertiary carbocation then reacts in one of two fast ways:
Route 1, substitution (SN1): a water molecule uses a lone pair on O to bond to the positive carbon, and the resulting ion loses H+:
(CH3)3C++H2O→(CH3)3C–O+H2→(CH3)3C–OH+H+
Route 2, elimination: instead of bonding to carbon, a solvent molecule removes an H+ from a β-carbon (one of the CH3 groups), and the C–H electron pair becomes the new C=C bond:
(CH3)3C+→(CH3)2C=CH2+H+
(ii) Route 1 (substitution) predominates, so 2-methylpropan-2-ol is the major product.
Water and ethanol are weak bases but reasonable nucleophiles, and they are present in large excess around the carbocation. Bonding to the positive carbon is therefore the more frequent outcome.
Elimination becomes the main route only with a strong base, such as alcoholic KOH, and at higher temperature. Neither is present here.
So under these mild, neutral solvolysis conditions substitution gives the major product and elimination the minor one.