Give reasons for the following:
(a) Transition metals show variable oxidation states.
(b) value for is negative while that for is positive.
(c) The highest oxidation state of Mn with fluorine is , whereas with oxygen it is .
Confirming your payment
Previous Year Questions · Question 26 of 37
Give reasons for the following:
(a) Transition metals show variable oxidation states.
(b) value for is negative while that for is positive.
(c) The highest oxidation state of Mn with fluorine is , whereas with oxygen it is .
(a) In transition metals, the and orbitals have very similar energies. So electrons can be lost from both, and a variable number of electrons can take part in bonding. The oxidation states differ by one unit, for example , , , , and Mn shows every state from to .
(b) The sign of depends on the net energy for (NCERT Table 4.4):

(c) The highest fluoride of Mn is , but the highest oxide is (and the oxoanion is ). The reason is that oxygen can form multiple bonds to the metal. Each O atom, in a bond, uses two electrons of the metal. Four O atoms around one Mn are enough to reach . Fluorine forms only single bonds, so reaching would need seven F atoms around one small Mn atom, which is not possible.