Both the carbonyl group () and the carbon–carbon double bond () contain one σ bond and one π bond, and both undergo addition reactions. Yet aldehydes and ketones undergo nucleophilic addition, whereas alkenes undergo electrophilic addition. Explain this difference, using the addition of HCN to ethanal and of HBr to propene as examples.
Practice Questions · Question 21 of 30
Both the carbonyl group ( >C=O ) and the carbon–carbon double bond ( >C=C< ) contain one σ bond and one π bond, and…
The difference comes from the polarity of the two double bonds, which decides which reagent attacks first.
The C=O group. Oxygen is much more electronegative than carbon, so the π electrons of C=O are pulled towards oxygen. The carbonyl carbon carries a partial positive charge and is an electrophilic centre:
So the first step is attack by a nucleophile (an electron-pair donor) on the carbon. The π electrons move onto oxygen, which is electronegative enough to hold the negative charge as an alkoxide ion. A proton then adds to the oxygen. With ethanal and HCN, the nucleophile is :
The C=C bond. Both atoms are carbon, so the bond is essentially non-polar. Its π electron cloud, above and below the plane, is an electron-rich region that attracts electrophiles. So the first step is attack by an electrophile ( from HBr) on the π electrons, giving a carbocation, which then combines with the nucleophile :
A nucleophile is not attracted by the non-polar, electron-rich C=C, and no atom of C=C can accept a negative charge the way oxygen does.

Summary: the polar C=O has an electron-poor carbon, so it is attacked first by a nucleophile; the non-polar C=C is electron-rich, so it is attacked first by an electrophile.
