(i) Phenol (pKa 10.0) is a stronger acid than water, so it gives its proton to the strong base OH−. But it is a weaker acid than carbonic acid (pKa about 6.4), so it cannot transfer a proton to the hydrogen carbonate ion and no CO2 is released. This is why phenol, unlike carboxylic acids, gives no effervescence with NaHCO3.
(ii) Phenol forms the salt sodium phenoxide:
C6H5OH+NaOH→C6H5ONa+H2O
(iii) The white precipitate is 2,4,6-tribromophenol:
C6H5OH+3Br2→C6H2Br3OH↓+3HBr
In water the −OH group so strongly activates the ring that all three ortho and para positions are brominated, with no catalyst needed.
(iv) The carbonate ion can accept two protons, one at a time, and each step has its own acid–base pair:
| Acid | Conjugate base | pKa |
|---|
| H2CO3 | HCO3− | about 6.4 |
| C6H5OH | C6H5O− | 10.0 |
| HCO3− | CO32− | about 10.3 |
A proton moves from the stronger acid (lower pKa) to the base of a weaker acid.
- First step (happens): phenol (pKa 10.0) is a slightly stronger acid than HCO3− (pKa about 10.3), so it gives its proton to CO32−. Phenol is converted into sodium phenoxide, which is soluble, so the phenol dissolves:
C6H5OH+Na2CO3→C6H5ONa+NaHCO3
- Second step (does not happen): to release CO2, the HCO3− formed would have to accept another proton and become H2CO3 (→CO2+H2O). Phenol is a much weaker acid than H2CO3 (pKa about 6.4), so it cannot do this, and no effervescence is seen. This is the same reason phenol gives no gas with NaHCO3 in part (i).
A carboxylic acid such as ethanoic acid (stronger than H2CO3) would complete both steps and give brisk effervescence; that is how the two classes are told apart.
