Phenol (pKa 10.0) is nearly a million times more acidic than ethanol (pKa 15.9). Both phenol and the phenoxide ion are resonance stabilised. Which statement correctly explains why resonance still favours the ionisation of phenol?
Practice Questions · Question 1 of 30
Phenol (pKa 10.0) is nearly a million times more acidic than ethanol (pKa 15.9).
(A) Phenol has more resonance structures than the phenoxide ion, so phenol is the more stabilised species.
(B) In the phenoxide ion the negative charge stays only on oxygen, so the ion cannot be delocalised.
- Correct answer
(C) The charge-delocalised structures of phenol separate a positive and a negative charge, but those of the phenoxide ion do not, so resonance stabilises the phenoxide ion more than phenol.
(D) Resonance strengthens the O–H bond of phenol, and a stronger O–H bond releases more easily.
Option (C) is correct.
Explanation: An acid ionises more readily when its conjugate base is stabilised more than the acid itself.
Both sides of this equilibrium have five resonance structures (NCERT, acidity of phenols):

- Phenol (I–V): in structures III, IV and V the oxygen carries a positive charge and a ring carbon a negative charge. Separating opposite charges costs energy, so these structures contribute little and phenol gains only a small resonance stabilisation.
- Phenoxide ion (VI–X): the ion already carries one negative charge, and resonance only moves that charge from oxygen to the two ortho carbons and the para carbon. No opposite charges are created, so all these structures contribute well and the ion is stabilised strongly.
The anion therefore gains more stability from resonance than the acid does, which shifts the equilibrium towards ionisation. In ethanol there is no resonance at all, and the ethyl group concentrates the charge on the ethoxide oxygen, so ethanol is a far weaker acid.
- (A) is wrong: phenol (I–V) and the phenoxide ion (VI–X) each have five structures; the difference is in their stability, not their number.
- (B) is wrong: structures VIII–X put the negative charge on the ortho and para carbons, so the charge is delocalised.
- (D) is wrong: in structures III–V the oxygen is positively charged, which pulls electrons towards it and weakens the O–H bond; a stronger bond would make ionisation harder, not easier.
