During an organic chemistry experiment, a student adds magnesium turnings to bromomethane in dry ether.
Question 83 marksMedium
During an organic chemistry experiment, a student adds magnesium turnings to bromomethane in dry ether.
(a) Identify the organic compound formed.
(b) Write the chemical equation for its formation.
(c) In bromomethane the carbon atom bonded to bromine carries a partial positive charge, but in the product the same carbon carries a partial negative charge. Explain this reversal.
(b) Magnesium inserts between the carbon and the bromine:
CH3Br+Mgdry etherCH3MgBr
(c) The polarity of a bond depends on which atom is more electronegative (Pauling values: Br 2.8, C 2.5, Mg 1.2).
In CH3–Br the carbon is bonded to the more electronegative bromine. The bonding pair is pulled towards Br, so the bond is Cδ+–Brδ− and the carbon is electron-poor (it is attacked by nucleophiles).
Magnesium inserts between C and Br. The carbon's new partner is magnesium, which is less electronegative (electropositive). The C–Mg bond is covalent but highly polar, with carbon pulling the electrons from magnesium: Cδ−–Mgδ+. The Mg–Br bond is essentially ionic.
So the same carbon atom changes from δ+ (electrophilic) in CH3Br to δ− (carbanion-like, nucleophilic and strongly basic) in CH3MgBr, because its bonding partner changes from an atom more electronegative than carbon to one much less electronegative.