Assertion (A): Methyl fluoride is preferred to methyl iodide for converting nucleophiles such as CN^- or NH₃ into…
Question 51 markMCQMedium
Assertion (A): Methyl fluoride is preferred to methyl iodide for converting nucleophiles such as CN− or NH3 into their methyl derivatives.
Reason (R): Alkyl fluorides are prepared by heating an alkyl chloride or bromide with a metallic fluoride such as AgF, Hg2F2, CoF2 or SbF3 (Swarts reaction), because direct fluorination of an alkane with F2 is too violent to control.
Select your answer
(A) Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A.
(B) Both A and R are true but R is not the correct explanation of A.
(C) A is true but R is false.
(D) A is false but R is true.
Correct answer
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation:
Assertion is false. To methylate a nucleophile, the CH3–X bond must break and X− must leave. The C–I bond is the weakest of the carbon–halogen bonds and the C–F bond the strongest (NCERT Table 6.2):
CH3I (C–I, 234 kJ mol−1) therefore reacts quickly and cleanly, while CH3F (C–F, 452 kJ mol−1) is almost inert towards nucleophiles. Methyl iodide is the reagent of choice; methyl fluoride would barely react.
Reason is true. Fluorine reacts with alkanes so violently that the reaction cannot be controlled and the carbon chain is broken up, so alkyl fluorides are not made by direct fluorination. Instead the fluorine is brought in by halogen exchange:
CH3Br+AgFΔCH3F+AgBr
The exchange works because the very strong C–F bond that forms makes the product stable.
The two statements are both about the C–F bond, but R describes how alkyl fluorides are made, not how they react, and it certainly does not support A.
(A) and (B) are wrong because A is false.
(C) is wrong because R is a true statement of the Swarts reaction.