A technician has two unlabelled bottles. One contains manganese(II) sulphate solution and the other zinc sulphate solution, both dilute and both of the same concentration (atomic numbers: Mn = 25, Zn = 30).
Explain how the two solutions could be told apart (a) by a magnetic measurement and (b) by their colour.
First write the configurations of the two ions. The 4s electrons are removed before the 3d electrons.
Mn=[Ar]3d54s2⇒Mn2+=[Ar]3d5
Zn=[Ar]3d104s2⇒Zn2+=[Ar]3d10
(a) By magnetic moment.Mn2+ has five 3d electrons in five separate orbitals, so n=5 unpaired electrons:
μ=n(n+2)=5×7=35=5.92BM
Zn2+ has all ten 3d electrons paired, so n=0 and μ=0. The manganese solution is strongly paramagnetic (it is attracted into a magnetic field, for example on a Gouy balance), while the zinc solution is diamagnetic (slightly repelled). The bottle that is attracted contains Mn2+.
(b) By colour. Colour needs a d–d transition: a d electron absorbs visible light and moves to a higher-energy d orbital. Mn2+ (3d5) has d electrons and room in the d orbitals, so its solution is pink (NCERT Table 4.8). Zn2+ (3d10) has a completely filled 3d subshell, so no d–d transition is possible and its solution is colourless.
The pink of Mn2+ is very pale, and a dilute solution can look almost colourless, so the colour test is less reliable than the magnetic test. The magnetic difference, 5.92 BM against 0 BM, is the largest possible in the 3d series and is unmistakable.