Two cylindrical rods of identical dimensions, one of rubber and the other of steel, are each fixed rigidly at one end to the roof. A mass is attached to the centre of the free end of each rod. Then
Practice Questions · Question 13 of 37
Two cylindrical rods of identical dimensions, one of rubber and the other of steel, are each fixed rigidly at one end…
(A) both rods elongate, but there is no perceptible change in shape
(B) the steel rod elongates and changes shape, but the rubber rod only elongates
(C) the steel rod elongates without any perceptible change in shape, but the rubber rod elongates and the shape of its bottom edge changes to an ellipse
- Correct answer
(D) the steel rod elongates without any perceptible change in shape, but the rubber rod elongates and its bottom edge tapers to a tip at the centre
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: The load is applied at one point, the centre of the free end, not spread over the whole face.
Steel has a very large Young's modulus. The extension is tiny, and the difference between the stretch at the centre and at the rim is far too small to see. The rod lengthens slightly and keeps its shape.
Rubber has a very small Young's modulus. The material at the centre, where the load is attached, is pulled much more than the material near the rim, and because rubber strains easily this difference is large. The centre of the bottom face is drawn out much farther than its edges, so the end tapers to a tip at the centre.
- (A) Rubber's shape change is large and clearly visible.
- (B) This swaps the two materials; it is the easily strained rubber that changes shape.
- (C) The load is symmetric about the axis of the rod, so the end stays symmetric about that axis; it has no reason to become elliptical.
