In nature, structural members usually fail because of large torques from twisting or bending rather than from tensile or compressive strains. This kind of structural breakdown is called buckling. In tall cylindrical structures like trees, the torque is caused by the tree's own weight bending it, so that the vertical through the centre of gravity no longer falls within the base. The elastic torque produced by this bending about the central axis of the tree is , where is the Young's modulus, is the radius of the trunk and is the radius of curvature of the bent surface (the neutral surface) along the height of the tree, which contains the centre of gravity. Estimate the critical height of a tree for a given radius of the trunk.
Practice Questions · Question 34 of 37
In nature, structural members usually fail because of large torques from twisting or bending rather than from tensile…
Let the tree have height and weight per unit volume . Its weight is , acting at the centre of gravity A, at height on the neutral surface.

Horizontal shift of the centre of gravity. When the tree bends into an arc of radius centred at B, A is displaced sideways by from the base. In the right triangle ABC, , and :
Since , the term can be neglected:
Condition for buckling. The weight acting at A has a torque about the base. The tree is just about to buckle when this equals the largest elastic torque the trunk can provide:
and cancel:
Critical height:
A taller tree would buckle under its own weight. The critical height grows only as , so taller trees need disproportionately thicker trunks.
