An earthquake sends two kinds of waves through the Earth: P waves, which are longitudinal, and S waves, which are transverse. Seismic stations on the far side of the Earth receive P waves but no direct S waves, which is evidence that the Earth's outer core is liquid. Which statement correctly explains why S waves do not pass through the liquid outer core?
Practice Questions · Question 4 of 37
An earthquake sends two kinds of waves through the Earth: P waves, which are longitudinal, and S waves, which are…
- Correct answer
(A) A transverse wave needs a medium that resists a change of shape, and a liquid cannot sustain a shearing stress.
(B) A liquid cannot be compressed, so no wave of any kind can travel through it.
(C) Longitudinal waves can travel only through solids, so the liquid core lets through only transverse waves.
(D) S waves travel so much faster than P waves that they leave the core before they can be detected.
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: In a transverse wave each layer of the medium is pushed sideways relative to its neighbour, which is a shear (a change of shape). The wave can move on only if the medium pulls the displaced layer back, that is, if it has a restoring force against shear. Solids have this, so S waves travel through the Earth's rocky mantle. A liquid simply flows when sheared; it has no shear restoring force, so a transverse wave dies out at the liquid outer core. A longitudinal wave needs only resistance to compression (a bulk modulus), which liquids do have, so P waves get through.
Option (B) is wrong: liquids do resist compression, and that is exactly what lets longitudinal P waves (and sound in water) travel through them.
Option (C) is wrong: it reverses the facts. Longitudinal waves travel through solids, liquids and gases, while transverse mechanical waves need a solid.
Option (D) is wrong: S waves are slower than P waves, and speed has nothing to do with whether a wave can exist in a medium; what matters is whether the medium can sustain shear.
