An open organ pipe and a closed organ pipe produce fundamental notes of the same frequency. The ratio of their lengths, , is
Practice Questions · Question 3 of 37
An open organ pipe and a closed organ pipe produce fundamental notes of the same frequency.
(A)
(B)
- Correct answer
(C)
(D)
Option (C) is correct.
Explanation: In its fundamental mode a pipe open at both ends has an antinode at each end and one node in the middle, so its length is half a wavelength. A pipe closed at one end has a node at the closed end and an antinode at the open end, so its length is a quarter wavelength. Hence
Setting the two fundamentals equal:
so . The open pipe must be twice as long because it fits only half a wavelength, while the closed pipe fits a quarter.
Option (A) is wrong: pipes of equal length do not share a fundamental; the closed pipe would sound an octave lower ( against ).
Option (B) is wrong: this inverts the ratio. With the open pipe the shorter one, its fundamental would be four times that of the closed pipe.
Option (D) is wrong: an open pipe one quarter the length of the closed pipe would have a fundamental eight times higher.
