(i) State three properties of a resonance hybrid.
(ii) The tert-butyl carbocation, , is more stable than the isopropyl carbocation, . Explain why.
Confirming your payment
Practice Questions · Question 33 of 37
(i) State three properties of a resonance hybrid.
(ii) The tert-butyl carbocation, , is more stable than the isopropyl carbocation, . Explain why.
(i) Properties of a resonance hybrid:
(a) Real structure: The contributing (canonical) structures are hypothetical; none of them alone represents the molecule. The actual molecule is the resonance hybrid, and each structure contributes in proportion to its stability.
(b) Greater stability: The hybrid has lower energy than any contributing structure. The difference between the energy of the hybrid and that of the most stable contributing structure is the resonance stabilisation energy. The more important contributing structures there are, and the more nearly equivalent they are, the greater the resonance energy.
(c) Bond lengths: The bond lengths in the hybrid lie between those of single and double bonds. For example, all C–C bonds in benzene are 139 pm, between C–C (154 pm) and C=C (134 pm). In nitromethane both N–O bonds are of equal length.
(ii) Both cations are stabilised by the +I effect of their methyl groups and by hyperconjugation. In hyperconjugation the σ electrons of a C–H bond on a carbon next to the positive carbon are delocalised into its vacant p orbital.
The tert-butyl cation also has three electron-releasing methyl groups against two. Its positive charge is therefore dispersed more, and it is more stable than the isopropyl cation (3° > 2°).