(i) The stability of carbocations is explained by:
- Inductive effect: alkyl groups release electrons (+I) towards the positive carbon and disperse its charge.
- Hyperconjugation: the σ electrons of C–H bonds next to the positive carbon are delocalised into its vacant p orbital.
- Resonance: if the positive carbon is next to a π bond, the charge is delocalised over more than one atom.
The more alkyl groups on the positive carbon, the greater the +I and hyperconjugative stabilisation. Order of increasing stability:
1∘<2∘<3∘
(ii) The allyl cation is more stable. Its positive carbon is next to a C=C bond, so the π electrons can shift towards the cationic carbon, giving two equivalent resonance structures:

The positive charge is spread equally over C-1 and C-3, and the resonance hybrid is more stable than either structure. The propyl cation is a primary carbocation. It has no π bond next to the positive carbon, so its charge stays on one carbon and is stabilised only weakly (by the +I effect of the ethyl group and hyperconjugation with two C–H bonds).