The atomic weights of some elements are: F 19, Cl 35.5, Br 80; S 32, Se 79, Te 128.
(a) Test whether S, Se, Te and whether F, Cl, Br obey Dobereiner's law of triads.
(b) What does the result for F, Cl, Br show about the law of triads?
Confirming your payment
Practice Questions · Question 30 of 37
The atomic weights of some elements are: F 19, Cl 35.5, Br 80; S 32, Se 79, Te 128.
(a) Test whether S, Se, Te and whether F, Cl, Br obey Dobereiner's law of triads.
(b) What does the result for F, Cl, Br show about the law of triads?
(a) In a triad the atomic weight of the middle element is about the average of the other two.
For S, Se, Te:
so S, Se and Te form a triad.
For F, Cl, Br:
so F, Cl and Br do not form a triad.
(b) Fluorine, chlorine and bromine are all halogens with very similar properties, yet they do not fit the rule. (Only Cl, Br and I make a triad: .) The law of triads therefore worked only for a few selected sets of elements and could not group all similar elements, which is why it was dismissed as coincidence.