(a) State the modern periodic law. What observation of Moseley led to it?
(b) The atomic masses and atomic numbers of three pairs of neighbouring elements are given below.
Pair
Atomic masses
Atomic numbers
Ar, K
39.9, 39.1
18, 19
Co, Ni
58.9, 58.7
27, 28
Te, I
127.6, 126.9
52, 53
Explain why arranging these elements by atomic mass gives a wrong order, and how the modern periodic law settles their positions.
(c) Helium is strictly an s-block element. Why is it placed in group 18 with the p-block elements?
(a) Modern periodic law: the physical and chemical properties of the elements are periodic functions of their atomic numbers. In 1913 Moseley studied the characteristic X-ray spectra of the elements and found that a plot of ν (ν = frequency of the X-rays emitted) against atomic number gave a straight line, whereas a plot against atomic mass did not. This showed that atomic number (the nuclear charge) is a more fundamental property than atomic mass, and Mendeleev's law was modified accordingly.
(b) In each pair the first element has the higher atomic mass, so an order by atomic mass would put K before Ar, Ni before Co and I before Te. That would place iodine in the same group as oxygen and sulphur and tellurium with the halogens, and potassium among the noble gases, which contradicts their properties. (Mendeleev himself placed iodine after tellurium on the basis of properties, assuming the atomic mass was wrong.) Atomic numbers increase in the order Ar (18) < K (19), Co (27) < Ni (28), Te (52) < I (53). Arranging by atomic number therefore puts every element in the group that matches its properties, with no need to break the rule: Ar with the noble gases, K with the alkali metals, Te in group 16 and I in group 17.
(c) Helium (1s2) has its last electron in an s orbital, so strictly it belongs to the s-block. It is placed in group 18 of the p-block because its valence shell is completely filled, and as a result it shows the properties of the other noble gases (very low reactivity).