Show that the relation in the set of real numbers, defined as is neither reflexive nor symmetric nor transitive.
Exercise 1.1 · Question 2 of 16
Show that the relation R in the set R of real numbers, defined as R = (a, b) : a ≤ b² is neither reflexive nor…
The relation is on the set of real numbers.
To show a property fails, one counterexample is enough. So for each property we hunt for a single bad case.
Not reflexive
Reflexivity would mean for every real , that is
Take . Then , and
So , and is not reflexive.
It is worth seeing where it goes wrong. rearranges to , i.e. , which holds for and for . So reflexivity fails exactly on the open interval .

Not symmetric
Symmetry would mean: whenever , also .
Take and :
- , because is true.
- , because is false.
So is not symmetric.
Not transitive
Transitivity would mean: whenever and , also .
Take , , :
- , because is true.
- , because is true.
- , because is false.
Squaring can shrink a number as well as grow it, so the two steps do not chain. Hence is not transitive.
Conclusion. is neither reflexive, nor symmetric, nor transitive.
