(i) A={1,2,…,14}, R={(x,y):3x−y=0}
First write the condition as a rule. 3x−y=0 means y=3x.
So a pair (x,y) belongs to R exactly when y is three times x — and both x and y must lie in A, because R is a relation in A.
Take each x in turn:
- x=1⇒y=3, and 3∈A, so (1,3)∈R
- x=2⇒y=6, and 6∈A, so (2,6)∈R
- x=3⇒y=9, and 9∈A, so (3,9)∈R
- x=4⇒y=12, and 12∈A, so (4,12)∈R
- x=5⇒y=15, but 15∈/A, so nothing is contributed; the same happens for every x≥5
Hence
R={(1,3),(2,6),(3,9),(4,12)}
Reflexive? We need (x,x)∈R for every x∈A. For (x,x) the condition reads 3x−x=0, i.e. 2x=0, i.e. x=0 — and 0∈/A. So not a single pair (x,x) is in R. For instance (1,1)∈/R, because 3(1)−1=2=0.
Therefore R is not reflexive.
Symmetric? We need: whenever (x,y)∈R, also (y,x)∈R. Test the pair (1,3)∈R. Is (3,1)∈R? That needs 3(3)−1=0, but 3(3)−1=8=0, so (3,1)∈/R.
One counterexample is enough. Therefore R is not symmetric.
Transitive? We need: whenever (x,y)∈R and (y,z)∈R, also (x,z)∈R. Here (1,3)∈R and (3,9)∈R, so transitivity would force (1,9)∈R. But 3(1)−9=−6=0, so (1,9)∈/R.
Therefore R is not transitive.
Conclusion. R is neither reflexive, nor symmetric, nor transitive.
The picture below shows the four pairs as arrows, together with the three arrows that are missing.

(ii) N, R={(x,y):y=x+5 and x<4}
The condition x<4 restricts the first entry to x=1,2,3 (natural numbers only), and then y=x+5:
- x=1⇒y=6
- x=2⇒y=7
- x=3⇒y=8
So
R={(1,6),(2,7),(3,8)}
Reflexive? (a,a)∈R would need a=a+5, which is false for every a. Also (1,1)∈/R. So R is not reflexive.
Symmetric? (1,6)∈R, but (6,1)∈/R: it would need 1=6+5 (false) and 6<4 (also false). So R is not symmetric.
Transitive? Transitivity only says something when two pairs link up, i.e. when (x,y)∈R and (y,z)∈R for the same middle element y. The second entries in R are 6,7,8; the first entries are 1,2,3. No number is both, because a first entry must satisfy x<4. So there is no linked pair at all, and the condition "if ... then ..." has nothing to check.
A statement of the form "if P then Q" is true whenever P never happens — this is called vacuous truth. Therefore R is transitive.
Conclusion. R is transitive, but neither reflexive nor symmetric.
(iii) A={1,2,3,4,5,6}, R={(x,y):y is divisible by x}
List, for each x, the multiples of x that lie in A:
R={ (1,1),(1,2),(1,3),(1,4),(1,5),(1,6),(2,2),(2,4),(2,6),(3,3),(3,6),(4,4),(5,5),(6,6) }
That is 14 pairs.
Reflexive? Every number divides itself, since x=1⋅x. So (x,x)∈R for all six elements: (1,1),(2,2),(3,3),(4,4),(5,5),(6,6)∈R.
Therefore R is reflexive.
Symmetric? (2,4)∈R because 4=2×2. But (4,2)∈/R, because 2 is not a multiple of 4.
Therefore R is not symmetric.
Transitive? Suppose (x,y)∈R and (y,z)∈R. Then y=kx and z=my for some positive integers k and m. Substituting,
z=m(kx)=(mk)x
and mk is a positive integer, so z is divisible by x, i.e. (x,z)∈R. For example (1,2)∈R and (2,6)∈R, and indeed (1,6)∈R.
Therefore R is transitive.
Conclusion. R is reflexive and transitive, but not symmetric.

(iv) Z, R={(x,y):x−y is an integer}
If x and y are integers then x−y is automatically an integer. So the condition is satisfied by every pair, and R=Z×Z.
Reflexive? x−x=0, which is an integer, so (x,x)∈R for every x∈Z. Reflexive.
Symmetric? If x−y is an integer, then y−x=−(x−y) is also an integer, so (y,x)∈R. Symmetric.
Transitive? If x−y and y−z are integers, then their sum
(x−y)+(y−z)=x−z
is an integer too, so (x,z)∈R. Transitive.
Conclusion. R is reflexive, symmetric and transitive, so it is an equivalence relation (it is the whole of Z×Z).
(v) A is the set of human beings in a town at a particular time
(a) R={(x,y):x and y work at the same place}
Reflexive: x works at the same place as x, so (x,x)∈R. Reflexive.
Symmetric: if x and y work at the same place, then y and x work at the same place — the phrase is unchanged when the two names are swapped. Symmetric.
Transitive: if x works where y works, and y works where z works, then x and z work at that same place. Transitive.
So R is an equivalence relation; its classes are the workplaces.
(b) R={(x,y):x and y live in the same locality}
This is the same pattern as (a) with "locality" in place of "workplace".
Reflexive: x lives in the same locality as x. Reflexive.
Symmetric: the condition reads the same both ways round. Symmetric.
Transitive: same locality as y, and y same locality as z, gives the same locality for x and z. Transitive.
So R is an equivalence relation; its classes are the localities.
(c) R={(x,y):x is exactly 7 cm taller than y}
Write h(x) for the height of x in centimetres. Then (x,y)∈R means h(x)=h(y)+7.
Reflexive: (x,x)∈R would need h(x)=h(x)+7, i.e. 0=7, which is false. Not reflexive.
Symmetric: if h(x)=h(y)+7, then h(y)=h(x)−7, so y is 7 cm shorter than x, not taller. So (y,x)∈/R. Not symmetric.
Transitive: if h(x)=h(y)+7 and h(y)=h(z)+7, then
h(x)=h(z)+14
so x is 14 cm taller than z, not 7 cm, and (x,z)∈/R. Not transitive.
Conclusion. Neither reflexive, nor symmetric, nor transitive.
(d) R={(x,y):x is wife of y}
Reflexive: nobody is her own wife, so (x,x)∈/R. Not reflexive.
Symmetric: if x is the wife of y, then y is the husband of x, so y is not the wife of x and (y,x)∈/R. Not symmetric.
Transitive: here we must be careful, and argue exactly what the definition demands. Transitivity says:
if (x,y)∈R and (y,z)∈R, then (x,z)∈R.
For the "if" part to happen we would need x to be the wife of y and y to be the wife of z at the same time. But if x is the wife of y, then y is a husband, so y is nobody's wife; there is no z with (y,z)∈R.
So the hypothesis of the transitivity statement is never satisfied: there is not one linked pair (x,y),(y,z) in R. An implication "if P then Q" counts as true whenever P is never true, because there is no case in which it could fail. This is vacuous truth, the same idea used in part (ii).
Therefore R is transitive — vacuously, not because any pair had to be checked.
Conclusion. R is transitive, but neither reflexive nor symmetric.
(e) R={(x,y):x is father of y}
Reflexive: nobody is his own father, so (x,x)∈/R. Not reflexive.
Symmetric: if x is the father of y, then y is a child of x and cannot be the father of x. Not symmetric.
Transitive: if x is the father of y and y is the father of z, then x is the grandfather of z, not the father, so (x,z)∈/R. Unlike (d), here the hypothesis really can happen (three generations), and the conclusion fails. Not transitive.
Conclusion. Neither reflexive, nor symmetric, nor transitive.
The nine verdicts collected together:
| Part | Relation | Reflexive | Symmetric | Transitive |
|---|
| (i) | 3x−y=0 on {1,…,14} | No | No | No |
| (ii) | y=x+5, x<4 on N | No | No | Yes (vacuously) |
| (iii) | y divisible by x on {1,…,6} | Yes | No | Yes |
| (iv) | x−y an integer on Z | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| (v)(a) | same workplace | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| (v)(b) | same locality | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| (v)(c) | exactly 7 cm taller | No | No | No |
| (v)(d) | x is wife of y | No | No | Yes (vacuously) |
| (v)(e) | x is father of y | No | No | No |