Aldehydes, Ketones and Carboxylic Acids · Question 18 of 28
Give plausible explanation for each of the following
Question 183 marksHard
Give plausible explanation for each of the following:
(i) Cyclohexanone forms cyanohydrin in good yield but 2,2,6-trimethylcyclohexanone does not.
(ii) There are two –NH2 groups in semicarbazide. However, only one is involved in the formation of semicarbazones.
(iii) During the preparation of esters from a carboxylic acid and an alcohol in the presence of an acid catalyst, the water or the ester should be removed as soon as it is formed.
(i) Cyanohydrin formation is a reversible nucleophilic addition: CN− attacks the carbonyl carbon and the carbon changes from trigonal (sp2, 120°) to tetrahedral (sp3, 109.5°).
In cyclohexanone the carbonyl carbon is flanked only by ring CH2 groups, so CN− can approach it easily and the tetrahedral cyanohydrin is not crowded: the equilibrium lies well on the product side.
In 2,2,6-trimethylcyclohexanone three methyl groups sit on the two carbons next to C=O. They hinder the approach of CN− and, in the product, the new –CN and –OH groups would be squeezed against the methyl groups. The equilibrium therefore lies towards the ketone, and the yield is poor.
(ii) Semicarbazide is H2N–CO–NH–NH2. The –NH2 attached directly to C=O, and the –NH– next to it, have their lone pairs delocalised onto the carbonyl oxygen by resonance (amide-type resonance, forms II and III). These nitrogens are therefore poor nucleophiles. The terminal –NH2 (on the –NH– that is not bonded to C=O) is not part of this resonance; its lone pair is free, so it alone attacks the carbonyl carbon of the aldehyde or ketone.
(iii) Acid-catalysed esterification is reversible:
RCOOH+R′OHH+RCOOR′+H2O
The same acid also catalyses the reverse reaction, hydrolysis of the ester. By Le Chatelier's principle, removing a product (water or the ester) as soon as it forms shifts the equilibrium to the right, so the reaction continues until almost all the acid is converted and the yield of ester is high.