| Test | Positive | Negative |
|---|
| (i) | Tollens' reagent, warm | propanal: silver mirror | propanone: no change |
| (ii) | Iodoform (I2 + NaOH) | acetophenone: yellow ppt of CHI3 | benzophenone: no ppt |
| (iii) | NaHCO3 solution | benzoic acid: brisk effervescence of CO2 | phenol: no effervescence |
| (iv) | NaHCO3 solution | benzoic acid: brisk effervescence | ethyl benzoate: no effervescence |
| (v) | Iodoform | pentan-2-one: yellow ppt | pentan-3-one: no ppt |
| (vi) | Tollens' reagent | benzaldehyde: silver mirror | acetophenone: no change |
| (vii) | Iodoform | ethanal: yellow ppt | propanal: no ppt |
Why each test works:
(i) Propanal is an aldehyde and is oxidised by Tollens' reagent; propanone is a ketone and is not (Fehling's solution also works: red-brown Cu2O with propanal only). Propanone also gives the iodoform test, which propanal does not.
CH3CH2CHO+2[Ag(NH3)2]++3OH−→CH3CH2COO−+2Ag↓+2H2O+4NH3
(ii) Acetophenone is a methyl ketone (CH3CO– group); benzophenone is not.
C6H5COCH3+3NaOI→C6H5COONa+CHI3↓+2NaOH
(iii) Benzoic acid (pKa 4.19) is stronger than carbonic acid and liberates CO2; phenol (pKa ≈ 10) is too weak. Alternatively, neutral FeCl3 gives a violet colour with phenol and a buff precipitate with benzoic acid.
C6H5COOH+NaHCO3→C6H5COONa+H2O+CO2↑
(iv) Only the free acid has an acidic –COOH hydrogen; the ester has none, so it does not react with NaHCO3.
(v) Pentan-2-one (CH3COCH2CH2CH3) is a methyl ketone; in pentan-3-one (C2H5COC2H5) the C=O carries two ethyl groups.
CH3COCH2CH2CH3+3NaOI→CH3CH2CH2COONa+CHI3↓+2NaOH
(vi) Benzaldehyde, an aldehyde, gives a silver mirror with Tollens' reagent (it does not respond to Fehling's test, since aromatic aldehydes do not). Acetophenone, a methyl ketone, gives the iodoform test instead.
(vii) Ethanal is the only aldehyde with a CH3CO– group, so it alone gives iodoform.
CH3CHO+3NaOI→HCOONa+CHI3↓+2NaOH
