is paramagnetic while is diamagnetic though both are tetrahedral. Why?
Coordination Compounds · Question 37 of 41
[NiCl₄]²- is paramagnetic while [Ni(CO)₄] is diamagnetic though both are tetrahedral. Why?
The two complexes differ in the oxidation state of nickel and in the strength of the ligand.
: CO is neutral, so nickel is in the zero oxidation state: Ni is . In the presence of the strong CO ligand the unpaired d electrons pair up, the 4s electrons also enter 3d, giving , and the empty 4s and 4p orbitals form hybrids (tetrahedral). With no unpaired electron the complex is diamagnetic.
: nickel is in the +2 oxidation state, . is a weak ligand and is unable to pair up the two unpaired 3d electrons. The 4s and 4p orbitals form hybrids (tetrahedral), and the two unpaired electrons make the ion paramagnetic.

So the same tetrahedral geometry can be diamagnetic or paramagnetic, depending on how many unpaired d electrons the metal is left with.
