Apart from tetrahedral geometry, another possible geometry for CH₄ is square planar with the four H atoms at the corners of the square and the C atom at its centre. Explain why CH₄ is not square planar?
Chemical Bonding and Molecular Structure · Question 21 of 40
Apart from tetrahedral geometry, another possible geometry for CH₄ is square planar with the four H atoms at the…
VSEPR argument: the C atom in CH₄ has four bond pairs and no lone pair. Electron pairs arrange themselves as far apart as possible to minimise repulsion. In a square planar arrangement the H–C–H angles would be 90°, whereas in a tetrahedral arrangement they are 109.5°. The bond pairs are farther apart in the tetrahedral arrangement, so repulsion is smaller and the molecule is more stable. Hence CH₄ is tetrahedral.
Hybridisation argument: in forming CH₄, carbon (excited state 2s¹ 2p_x¹ 2p_y¹ 2p_z¹) undergoes sp³ hybridisation. The four sp³ hybrid orbitals are directed towards the corners of a regular tetrahedron, so the four C–H bonds point tetrahedrally. A square planar shape would need a different type of hybridisation involving a d orbital, which carbon does not have in its valence shell.
