What is the basic difference in approach between the Mendeleev's Periodic Law and the Modern Periodic Law?
Classification of Elements and Periodicity in Properties · Question 3 of 40
What is the basic difference in approach between the Mendeleev's Periodic Law and the Modern Periodic Law?
The two laws differ in the property taken as the basis of periodicity.
Mendeleev's Periodic Law: the properties of the elements are a periodic function of their atomic weights. Elements were therefore arranged in order of increasing atomic weight.
Modern Periodic Law: the physical and chemical properties of the elements are periodic functions of their atomic numbers. Elements are arranged in order of increasing atomic number.
The change came from Moseley's work (1913): a plot of of the characteristic X-rays of elements against atomic number gave a straight line, whereas a plot against atomic mass did not. This showed that atomic number (the nuclear charge, equal to the number of electrons in the neutral atom) is the more fundamental property. Since the electronic configuration depends on the atomic number, the modern law also removes anomalies of Mendeleev's table such as the Te–I order.
