Option (D) is correct.
Explanation:
A counterexample must have one pair of opposite sides parallel and the other pair equal (X true) but must not be a parallelogram (Y false).
Shape (D) is an isosceles trapezium. Take its corners as A(0, 0), B(8, 0), C(6, 4), D(2, 4) on a centimetre grid. AB and DC are both horizontal, so AB ∥ DC. The other sides have
AD2=22+42=20,BC2=22+42=20
so AD = BC. But AD slants to the right and BC slants to the left, so AD is not parallel to BC, and AB = 8 cm while DC = 4 cm. It is not a parallelogram. X is true and Y is false, so Shape (D) disproves Neel's claim.
Why the other options are wrong
- (A) The rectangle is a parallelogram, so Y is true for it. It agrees with the claim.
- (B) The rhombus is a parallelogram (both pairs of opposite sides are parallel), so it agrees with the claim.
- (C) The kite has no pair of parallel sides, so the 'if' part is false for it. The claim says nothing about it.