Sameer notices that , and are all multiples of 3. He writes: "' is a prime greater than 3' implies ' is a multiple of 3'." (Here is a positive integer.)
Which option gives the converse of Sameer's proposition together with a correct verdict?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 23 of 40
Sameer notices that , and are all multiples of 3. He writes: "' is a prime greater than 3' implies ' is a multiple of 3'." (Here is a positive integer.)
Which option gives the converse of Sameer's proposition together with a correct verdict?
(A) "If is a multiple of 3, then is a prime greater than 3." It is true.
(B) "If is a multiple of 3, then is a prime greater than 3." It is false: .
(C) "If is not a prime greater than 3, then is not a multiple of 3." It is true for every .
(D) "If is a multiple of 3, then is a prime greater than 3." It is false, and is a counterexample.
Option (B) is correct.
Explanation:
Sameer's proposition is "If is a prime greater than 3, then is a multiple of 3." Its converse is "If is a multiple of 3, then is a prime greater than 3."
Test , which is not prime:
So is a multiple of 3, but 25 is not a prime. This is a counterexample: the converse is false.
(Sameer's proposition itself is true: a prime greater than 3 is not a multiple of 3, so its square is 1 more than a multiple of 3, and adding 2 gives a multiple of 3.)
Why the other options are wrong