Ishita's group gets three small lamps, X, Y and Z, each wrapped in paper so that only its two wires stick out. On every lamp the wires are labelled P and Q. The group joins each lamp to a two-cell battery, first with wire P on the + terminal and then with wire Q on the + terminal. Their teacher says that at least one of the lamps is an LED. The group's record is shown below.
| Lamp | P on the + terminal | Q on the + terminal |
|---|---|---|
| X | Glows | Glows |
| Y | Glows | Does not glow |
| Z | Does not glow | Does not glow |
(i) Which lamp is an LED? How do you know?
(ii) When the paper is removed, which of Y's two wires will be the longer one?
(iii) Ishita's friend says that Z is "just an LED joined the wrong way". Evaluate this claim using the table. What could Z be, and how could the group check?
