Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 59 of 80
A loop of area A carrying a current I , when placed in an external magnetic field B , experiences a torque.
Question 594 marksHard
A loop of area A carrying a current I, when placed in an external magnetic field B, experiences a torque.
(a) What is the direction of the torque with respect to the plane of the loop?
(b) Can the loop rotate around itself like a spin wheel due to this torque? Give a reason for the answer.
(c) What is the shape of the graph between torque and angle θ, as θ varies between 0 and 180∘? Represent it pictorially.
(d) State the orientation of the loop with respect to the external magnetic field in which the total magnetic flux through its area is minimum. Does this orientation constitute stable or unstable equilibrium?
Concepts used — torque and energy of a current loop in a uniform field
A plane loop of area A carrying a current I has magnetic moment m=IAn^, where n^ is the unit normal to the loop (right-hand rule with the current). In a uniform field B:
τ=m×B,τ=IABsinθU=−m⋅B=−mBcosθ
Here θ is the angle between m (the normal) and B. An equilibrium is stable where U is a minimum and unstable where U is a maximum.
(a) Direction of the torque
τ=m×B is perpendicular to m. Since m is along the normal to the loop, the torque is perpendicular to the normal, so it lies in the plane of the loop.
Answer: the torque vector lies in the plane of the loop, along the axis about which the loop tends to turn.
(b) Can the loop spin about its own axis?
Spinning like a wheel about its own axis (the normal) would need a torque alongm. The magnetic torque is always perpendicular to m, so it has no component along the normal.
Answer: No. The torque can only tilt the loop, turning m towards B. It can never spin the loop about its own axis.
(c) Torque against angle
τ=IABsinθ
θ=0∘: τ=0;
θ=90∘: τ=IAB, the maximum;
θ=180∘: τ=0 again.
Answer: a sine curve (one half-cycle): zero at 0∘, rising to the maximum IAB at 90∘ and falling back to zero at 180∘.
(d) Orientation of minimum total flux
Step 1 — Total flux. The total flux through the loop is the flux of its own field (fixed in size, and directed along m inside the loop, so counted positive) plus the flux of the external field:
Φtotal=Φself+BAcosθ
Step 2 — Minimum.cosθ is least, −1, at θ=180∘. So Φtotal is minimum when m is antiparallel to B: the plane of the loop is perpendicular to B and the loop's own field opposes the external field.
Step 3 — Stability. At θ=180∘:
U=−mBcos180∘=+mB
This is the maximum possible energy. The torque there is zero, but after a slight tilt the torque turns the loop further away, towards θ=0∘.
Answer: the total flux is minimum when the loop's magnetic moment is antiparallel to B (loop plane perpendicular to B, its own field opposing it). This is unstable equilibrium.
Note: the opposite orientation, m parallel to B (θ=0∘), gives the maximum total flux and the minimum energy U=−mB: stable equilibrium.